Popular tags not in internal presets (2/2)

[Don-vip]

This is the follow-up of #12102 for 15.12 milestone:

Tag (wiki)	Count (taginfo)	Decision
​bicycle=dismount	​37307	Ignored for now, see #9158
​bin=yes	​22245	Added
​building=civic	​53949	Ignored for now, controversial tag
​building=hotel	​21776	Added
​building=houseboat	​11520	Ignored, not a building
​building=kindergarten	​13125	Added
​building=manufacture	​94507	Added
​building=public	​39377	Ignored for now, controversial tag
​building=service	​95527	Added
​building=static_caravan	​26023	Ignored, not a building
​building=train_station	​13938	Added
​cuisine=coffee_shop	​16997
​entrance=staircase	​66237
​footway=crossing	​135476	Added
​footway=sidewalk	​217915	Added
​golf=bunker	​64675
​golf=fairway	​24191
​highway=proposed	​51018	Ignored for now, see #11139
​historic=building	​11875
​landuse=conservation	​24867
​leisure=recreation_ground	​27747
​locality=townland	​48104	Ignored (only used in Ireland)
​man_made=mast	​23646	............ see #10759
​man_made=silo	​41194	............ see #11915
​place=allotments	​12582
​railway=signal	​40435	Added
​railway=stop	​11325
​route=foot	​26924	............ see #10991
​ruins=yes	​33287
​seamark=buoy	​10212	Deprecated
​trolley_wire=yes	​34577
​waterway=rapids	​44573	Keep the situation as is for now. Difficult case. Was removed from mappaint in r8135 and r8767. The tag is clearly garbage, however there is no replacement, so a deprecation warning is not possible.

[Klumbumbus]

​I asked tumsi and he allows us to use the golf svg icons. He also maybe can create new icons if needed for the tags in Presets/Golf_Course, which do not have an icon. (I did not yet check the tags).

[Don-vip]

In 9089/josm:

see #12135 - add bin to public_transport=platform and highway=bus_stop. Reuse translation of amenity=waste_basket

[Don-vip]

In 9090/josm:

see #12135 - add footway=crossing/sidewalk to highway=footway

[Klumbumbus]

In 9091/josm:

see #12135 - add seamark=buoy to mappaint and preset; remove old deprecated tags section in elemstyles.mapcss

[Klumbumbus]

buoy icon [o31800]

[Klumbumbus]

In 9092/josm:

see #12135 - add railway=signal to mappaint and preset

[Klumbumbus]

railway signal icon ​[o31801]

[malcolmh]

"seamark=buoy" is a 'dead' tag. It belongs to a tagging scheme that was proposed back in 2009, but subsequently abandoned. The number of objects which have this tag has been steadily decreasing since then. The 'live' tagging scheme, uses the tag "seamark:type=*". There are some 47000 buoy objects with this tagging and the number has increased fourfold since 2009. Of the 10000 objects with "seamark=buoy", some 7000 of those also have the "seamark:type=*" tag. There is already a preset for the "seamark:type" tagging (​https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OpenSeaMap/josm/master/INT-1-preset.xml)

Please do not include "seamark=buoy" as a standard preset.

[Klumbumbus]

Thanks for clarification.

[Klumbumbus]

In 9093/josm:

see #12135 - remove seamark=buoy and add deprecated warning; fix icon size of railway=signal

[Klumbumbus]

In 9094/josm:

see #12135 - ignore seamark:type tags in missing tags validation test

[Don-vip]

In 9137/josm:

see #12135 - ignore locality=townland (only used in Ireland)

[Don-vip]

In 9138/josm:

see #12135 - add building=hotel/service/train_station to default presets

[anonymous]

hi , can you please add "amenity=social_facility" to the list ? It's very popular tag , we have 40000 use and we don't have preset for this tag.

[Atalanttore]

You should add ​end_date, because start_date is already in JOSM.

Another key I would like is ​cemetery=grave.

Regards,
Ettore

[anonymous]

Hi Don-vip , I re opened this ticket #12190 , and I written reasons in this ticket.

[anonymous]

hi , can you give me the answer ?

[Don-vip]

will you please stop asking every day? We treat tickets when we have time to do it, please be patient.

[Don-vip]

In 9157/josm:

see #12135 - add building=kindergarten/manufacture to default presets