Extend utility=* to buildings, street cabinets and industrial landuses

[francois.lacombe]

Dear maintainers,

Following the review of Utility facilities proposal, some changes occurs in the usage of utility=* key.
All necessary documentation is almost up to date, I hope nothing is missing so far.
​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Utility_facilities

Is it possible to update man_made=street_cabinet preset with following points please?

• Optional utility=* combobox with same values as used in combination with marker=*.
• Remove street_cabinet=power,water,telelcom,gas,street_lighting,cable_tv,water_management values.
• Colors should be common to utility=* values as of now and it may simplify default style.

Add utility=* combo box to building=service and building=industrial presets
It could be possible to use utility=* to color such buildings if appropriate.

As a side note, I think utility=* should be restricted to power,telecom,television and street_lighting values in combination with man_made=utility_pole (#20270 #21587).

Add following validation rules :

• street_cabinet=poweris replaced by utility=power
• street_cabinet=water, street_cabinet=water_management are replaced by utility=water
• street_cabinet=sewerage is replaced by utility=sewerage
• street_cabinet=gas and street_cabinet=gas_management are replaced by utility=gas
• street_cabinet=telecom, street_cabinet=communication, street_cabinet=telephone and street_cabinet=broadband are replaced by utility=telecom
• street_cabinet=cable_tv is replaced by utility=television
• street_cabinet=street_lighting is replaced by utility=street_lighting
• industrial=gas is deprecated and replaced by utility=gas

Let me know if any additional documentation is required

Best regards

[aceman]

Yes it is also needed to update the preset for street_cabinet in JOSM core. Now people are already converting cabinets to utility and it is a pity JOSM still produces new 'street_cabinet' tags which should be 'utility'.

​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:man_made%3Dstreet_cabinet

[francois.lacombe]

Hello

I missed and completely second your comment aceman.

It is the first point of this ticket: update man_made=street_cabinet preset with utility=* and remove corresponding vaues of street_cabinet=*.