Opened 11 years ago
Closed 10 years ago
#9897 closed defect (fixed)
Move map no longer works on OSX
| Reported by: | escada | Owned by: | team |
|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | blocker | Milestone: | 14.04 |
| Component: | Core | Version: | tested |
| Keywords: | Cc: | Stereo |
Description
I've just downloaded josm.jpnl version 6950. I work on OSX 10.9.2
The ctrl-click to move the map no longer works. I just get the select rectangle.
The same problem was also reported by another user on the forum: http://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?id=24885
Attachments (3)
Change History (39)
comment:1 by , 11 years ago
follow-up: 4 comment:2 by , 11 years ago
| Owner: | changed from to |
|---|---|
| Status: | new → needinfo |
Please post your status report.
comment:3 by , 11 years ago
The last version that I used that worked was 6891. However, that was the application (thus not via Java Web Start) and was running under Java 6.
I was running that version on the same OS.
comment:4 by , 11 years ago
Replying to Don-vip:
Please post your status report.
It is good that you can restrict the problem to 6891-6950. Very little happened between these versions, that might have affected the mouse handling. This makes it more likely that the switch from Java 6 to Java 7 or the switch from the downloaded version to Java Web Start has caused the problem.
In any case, it would be nice to sort out this problem, in particular as you are not the only affected user.
Therefore could you please post a status report, as Don-vip requested? In addition, please download the *.jar file for JOSM 6950 and 6891 and try both versions again with Java 7. (See here InstallNotes in case you are having problems to start the *.jar file.)
comment:5 by , 11 years ago
I have the same problem with JOSM 6891 (downloaded the snapshot jar) under java 7. Do you need the status report for this as well ?
The OSX Java app 6891 running under Java 6 works fine.
jar 6891 also works fine under Java 6
comment:6 by , 11 years ago
Thanks for the reports. It seems that the JOSM version does not matter, neither the way you launch it (webstart, OSX app or jar file). But the way how ctrl+left mouse button is handled has changed in Java 7 compared to Java 6.
Could you please check if ctrl+click map move works in the Download dialog? Does the context menu pop up if you ctrl+click the main map with a TMS-layer (e.g. Bing) present?
comment:8 by , 11 years ago
| Milestone: | → 14.04 |
|---|
comment:9 by , 11 years ago
Could you please check if ctrl+click map move works in the Download dialog?
It doesn't.
Does the context menu pop up if you ctrl+click the main map with a TMS-layer (e.g. Bing) present?
It doesn't.
comment:10 by , 11 years ago
ctrl+click in the download dialog does not work neither.
As soon as I right+click on the main map with a TMS-layer, the help text for the selection appears in the bottom right. No context menu
comment:11 by , 11 years ago
A temporary workaround is to use the ^-arrow shortcuts to move the map.
comment:12 by , 11 years ago
| Cc: | added |
|---|
comment:13 by , 11 years ago
| Owner: | changed from to |
|---|---|
| Status: | needinfo → new |
comment:15 by , 10 years ago
I've added some debugging output to investigate the problem. Please download version 6988 or later and start it with the --debug command line option.
$ java -jar josm-latest.jar --debug
Then open the Download dialog and try to move the map with the mouse, as if it would work. Report the command line output (the lines starting with (#9897). It should look something like this:
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 3 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 0 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 0 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 0 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 0 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 0 Modifiers: 1000000000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 3 Modifiers: 100000000
Most important for Java 7, but also for Java 6, if it's not too much trouble.
comment:16 by , 10 years ago
This is [6988] on Java 7:
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 1 Modifiers: 10000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 1 Modifiers: 10000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 1 Modifiers: 10000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000 (#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 1 Modifiers: 10000000
comment:19 by , 10 years ago
I've just tried the latest build, and it's, well, almost but not entirely not fixed. The map now moves, but the selection rectangle still appears.
comment:20 by , 10 years ago
comment:22 by , 10 years ago
| Resolution: | → fixed |
|---|---|
| Status: | new → closed |
follow-up: 27 comment:23 by , 10 years ago
| Resolution: | fixed |
|---|---|
| Status: | closed → reopened |
Sorry for the delay. I confirm it's still drawing the unwanted selection rectangle when ctrl-dragging the map in 6997/josm
comment:24 by , 10 years ago
If it helps, here is the debug output for a move.
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mousePressed: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) move start
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseDragged: Button 1 Modifiers: 10010000000
(#9897) moving
(#9897) DefaultMapController.mouseReleased: Button 1 Modifiers: 10000000
(#9897) move stop
comment:25 by , 10 years ago
Do you have the same behaviour if you:
- first press control key, then click & move mouse
- first click, then press control key, then move mouse ?
comment:27 by , 10 years ago
| Resolution: | fixed |
|---|---|
| Status: | closed → reopened |
Replying to Stereo:
Sorry for the delay. I confirm it's still drawing the unwanted selection rectangle when ctrl-dragging the map in 6997/josm
Thanks for the feedback! As I don't have access to a Mac, it takes a few iterations to get this right.
- Do you get selection rectangle in the download dialog, when moving the map?
- What about Draw nodes (A) map mode? Does it start a new line when you end the map movement?
comment:28 by , 10 years ago
Do you have the same behaviour if you:
- first press control key, then click & move mouse
- first click, then press control key, then move mouse ?
In the download dialog, I don't. The map isn't dragged when I click-ctrl. It is dragged when I ctrl-click. The rectangle is drawn in both cases.
In the map data display, the issue is solved. The map is dragged when I ctrl-click, and turns from a selection rectangle to a dragging pointer when I click-ctrl. In any case, it turns back into a normal pointer when I release ctrl but keep dragging, but I'm not sure what behaviour I would expect in this case anyway.
- Do you get selection rectangle in the download dialog, when moving the map?
When ctrl-dragging in the download dialog, and, as you'd expect, when dragging with no modifier key in both the download dialog and the map data display.
comment:30 by , 10 years ago
Could you please check if the selection rectangle for ctrl-drag moving in download dialog is fixed in r7011?
I'm still interested in this:
- What about Draw nodes (A) map mode? Does it start a new line when you end the map movement?
follow-up: 33 comment:31 by , 10 years ago
In download dialog (under OSX 10.9.2, JOSM 7056):
- clic+drag: select
- ctrl+right-clic+drag: select + drag
- right-clic+drag: drag
Same behavior with trackpad and a real mouse.
In draw mode (A):
- right-click: it behaves normally (no node created).
- ctrl-click: a node is created... :(
Another annoying "new" (at least back to version 7000) thing in the edit window: ctrl-drag used to "snap" objects to closest one, now it does drag the map (and try to snap too if you're close enough) :(
comment:32 by , 10 years ago
What about Draw nodes (A) map mode? Does it start a new line when you end the map movement?
It doesn't start a new line, but it does draw a point when I ctrl-click to start dragging. It would be nice if ctrl-clicking just started dragging without adding a point.
(I'm not 100% sure I understood your question)
follow-up: 34 comment:33 by , 10 years ago
Hi cquest, thank you for taking the time and testing on OSX. Can you verify that in r6988 and earlier you had the same problems as described at the top of this ticket?
Replying to cquest:
In download dialog (under OSX 10.9.2, JOSM 7056):
- clic+drag: select
- ctrl+right-clic+drag: select + drag
- right-clic+drag: drag
I may not understand correctly, but I thought that a regular Mac mouse has no right button and you instead use the single mouse button with Ctrl pressed. So what I really would be interested in is ctrl+click-drag.
What about Draw nodes (A) map mode? Does it start a new line when you end the map movement?
It doesn't start a new line, but it does draw a point when I ctrl-click to start dragging. It would be nice if ctrl-clicking just started dragging without adding a point.
Are you sure you don't get a rubber band after releasing Ctrl and mouse button (like you would if you click without Ctrl)?
Another annoying "new" (at least back to version 7000) thing in the edit window: ctrl-drag used to "snap" objects to closest one, now it does drag the map (and try to snap too if you're close enough) :(
You are right, the snapping should probably be turned off for OSX then, thanks for reporting the problem.
comment:34 by , 10 years ago
Replying to bastiK:
Hi cquest, thank you for taking the time and testing on OSX. Can you verify that in r6988 and earlier you had the same problems as described at the top of this ticket?
Replying to cquest:
In download dialog (under OSX 10.9.2, JOSM 7056):
- clic+drag: select
- ctrl+right-clic+drag: select + drag
- right-clic+drag: drag
I may not understand correctly, but I thought that a regular Mac mouse has no right button and you instead use the single mouse button with Ctrl pressed. So what I really would be interested in is
ctrl+click-drag.
Laptops have trackpads, which do provide "right click" (double finger click), so you can do ctrl+right-click
Desktops using apple mouse also provide right-click
I'm using a basic USB logitech mouse on my desktop, and the trackpad or same kind of mouse on my laptop.
ctrl-click-drag looks better in today's latest (7120) but not perfect.
When ctrl-click happens near an objet, it get selected and moved slightly which was not happening in past versions (like for example 6502).
After testing in both select (S) and add (A) modes, it looks like releasing the mouse (mouse-up) is acting like a mouse-down.
What about Draw nodes (A) map mode? Does it start a new line when you end the map movement?
It doesn't start a new line, but it does draw a point when I ctrl-click to start dragging. It would be nice if ctrl-clicking just started dragging without adding a point.
Are you sure you don't get a rubber band after releasing Ctrl and mouse button (like you would if you click without Ctrl)?
Another annoying "new" (at least back to version 7000) thing in the edit window: ctrl-drag used to "snap" objects to closest one, now it does drag the map (and try to snap too if you're close enough) :(
You are right, the snapping should probably be turned off for OSX then, thanks for reporting the problem.
This is not fixed in 7120.
comment:35 by , 10 years ago
I wanted to try to reproduce this, but am not even sure I can understand what the remaining bug is anymore. Cquest, if you can still reproduce unwanted behaviour, would opening a new ticket be ok with you?
What was the last version that worked? Did you run it on the same system?
(Older JOSM versions can be downloaded here.)