Reservoir preset is using deprecated tag

[Debeet]

Per ​wiki:

The landuse=reservoir tag "deprecated", the new scheme is natural=water + water=reservoir. This new scheme was introduced by water details proposal [...]

Old tag landuse=reservoir should be replaced with these two:

natural=water
water=reservoir

[skyper]

Replying to Debeet:

Per ​wiki:

The landuse=reservoir tag "deprecated", the new scheme is natural=water + water=reservoir. This new scheme was introduced by water details proposal [...]

This is wrong. Landuse=reservoir was never deprecated. It is even unclear if it is the same as water=reservoir as it might define the whole area with infrastructure and not only the water part.

Old tag landuse=reservoir should be replaced with these two:

natural=water
water=reservoir

You can use both tags at the same time and you are welcome to create and publish a preset but maybe you should solve a ​problem with water=* first as it has two different (exclusive) uses or does following fit ?

natural=water
water=lake;intermittent

[skyper]

​Discussion on tagging@

[Zverikk]

water=intermittent and water=tidal are imported values, briefly described in this proposal: ​http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Water_cover I believe it's not active (and never has been), and no one should use those tag values.

The correct way to map an intermittent lake is natural=water + water=lake + intermittent=yes.

[Klumbumbus]

JOSM has preset and mappaint support for the natural=water + water=* tagging schema.

For landuse=reservoir the wiki page states now, that it is not deprecated.

So wontfix for now.