Relation editor generates conflicts

[Nakor]

The following scenario works fine in 2454 but is broken in 2466

With the remote plugin get ​http://localhost:8111/import?url=http://api.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/relation/255174

Open the relation editor and download all members.
Delete any members and click OK.

FIRST ISSUE: a conflict is created because the relation was supposedly modified outside the editor.

Accept the conflict
Try to resolve the conflict

SECOND ISSUE: my version still have the member that I just deleted

Accept their version (with one member removed) and close the conflict resolution

Try to upload

THIRD ISUUE: JOSM pretends there is nothing to upload

[anonymous]

Same bug in 2468.

[anonymous]

Any change on a relation is not working any longer (also working on 2468).
When commiting the change (OK click) you always get the error popup:

Relation was changed outside the editor...

regards

peter

[anonymous]

Replying to anonymous:

Any change on a relation is not working any longer (also working on 2468).

I've better written: I am also working on 2468 at the moment.

[Gubaer]

I can't reproduce. If I download ​http://api.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/relation/255174 with "File->Open location" , edit the relation and click "OK" everything is fine.

If I edit any other relation or if I create a new relation everything is fine.

Is t his only happening when the relation is loaded through the remotecontrol plugin?

[kay_D]

Can be easily reproduces here (2466):

Just download *any* area (that contains a relation). Open the relation editor with any relation.
Edit anything in the relation editor, e.g. change or add a "name" tag. Try to exit the relation editor - it will come up with the error message "Relation was changed outside the editor" (in German, for me).

[Gubaer]

Confirmed, very easy to reproduce. Don't know why I didn't run into it three hours earlier.

[stoecker]

In r2481.

[anonymous]

Ticket #3986 has been marked as a duplicate of this ticket.

[Nakor]

I found a situation where it happens in 2481:

Open attached file and modifiy role of way 41286010 from none to south, the try to close the relation window.

[Gubaer]

Can't reproduce in r2486 with the data you've attached. Closing as worksforme.