Opened 13 months ago
Last modified 12 months ago
#23935 needinfo task
Add addr:streetnumber for same function like addr:housenumber in Addresses.java
Reported by: | afhafkartograf | Owned by: | afhafkartograf |
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | normal | Milestone: | |
Component: | Core validator | Version: | |
Keywords: | Cc: |
Description
Tag addr:streetnumber in Czechia and Slovakia has same rule likes addr:housenumber in world. Please add tag addr:streetnumber for Czechia and Slovakia and exclude addr:housenumber for check Duplicate house numbers in Adresses.java if is not possible to build it in MapCSS.
Attachments (0)
Change History (2)
follow-up: 2 comment:1 by , 12 months ago
Owner: | changed from | to
---|---|
Status: | new → needinfo |
comment:2 by , 12 months ago
Replying to taylor.smock:
What is the difference between
addr:streetnumber
andaddr:housenumber
? Why isaddr:streetnumber
used overaddr:housenumber
?
Looking at the addr:streetnumber and addr:housenumber wiki pages, I'm not certain why
addr:streetnumber
is necessary. There are 4792 uses outside of CZ and SK, so the tag is highly region specific, and I suspect that uses outside of CZ and SK are accidental. 5,898,490 uses are inside CZ and SK, so 99.9% of all uses are in two countries.
Checking in validator for duplicate house numbers has based on rule of street numbering whether are two same house numbers in street. There's rule that in one street it must not be two same house numbers related to street. But addr:conscriptionnumber and addr:provisionalnumber have house numbers related to district or municipality, the can be more same house numbers in street. And addr:streetnumber has rule that in can be only one value of street number related to street.
Maybe adding if address has addr:conscriptionnumber or addr:provisionalnumber and hasn't addr:streetnumber -> ingore checking addr:housenumber and if address has addr:streetnumber -> check like addr:housenumber in other countries can solve this problem.
What is the difference between
addr:streetnumber
andaddr:housenumber
? Why isaddr:streetnumber
used overaddr:housenumber
?Looking at the addr:streetnumber and addr:housenumber wiki pages, I'm not certain why
addr:streetnumber
is necessary. There are 4792 uses outside of CZ and SK, so the tag is highly region specific, and I suspect that uses outside of CZ and SK are accidental. 5,898,490 uses are inside CZ and SK, so 99.9% of all uses are in two countries.