indication of "man_made=lamp" in changelog 2022-11-01 Stable release18583

[leni]

In the changelog it says :

• Add/improve/fix/change Internal Presets, Map Paint Style and Validation rules
  • Ignore
    • man_made=lamp (needs icon, broader than highway=street_lamp)

man_made=lamp is used in osm but the proposed feature has been abandoned ​osmwiki:Proposed_features/Tag:man_made%3Dlamp

I don't understand why it is indicated in josm without more documentation work.

[skyper]

Thanks for the hint. The proposal was even rejected on a first voting cycle and later abandoned in favor of ​osmwiki:Proposed_features/Key:light_source. E.g. ​osmwiki:Tag:man_made=lamp needs a rework and a link to ​osmwiki:Key:light_source.

Anyway, the only task on JOSM side is to rewrite the line in the changelog.

[skyper]

Is it better now? See diff.

[taylor.smock]

That is interesting. When I was looking into the tag, the wiki didn't indicate that it was a rejected proposal and the ​taginfo chronology didn't look like a mass import.

Anyway, I've updated the wiki pages for it with the rejected status. @leni: please do that in the future first.

[leni]

Sorry I didn't know "status" in the wiki.
After, your update has been removed, I put a message to the editor ​User_talk:Something_B#Tag:man_made=lamp

[taylor.smock]

I noticed. I'm not particularly interested in getting involved in tagging disputes, so I'll let the people with an interest in the subject discuss it between themselves.

[skyper]

I have changed the status from "De facto" to "In use" and added a warning banner.
Overall man_made=lamp is not ready for defaultpresets.

[taylor.smock]

Makes me glad I just added it to the ignore list. :)

[leni]

I agree with both of you.