Opened 8 months ago
Last modified 8 months ago
#22284 new enhancement
Warn about indoor=no inside and indoor=yes outside of a building polygon
Reported by: | skyper | Owned by: | team |
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | normal | Milestone: | |
Component: | Core validator | Version: | |
Keywords: | indoor building | Cc: |
Description
I recently found objects with indoor=no
inside a building polygon. Without any or identical value of layer=*
this should trigger a warning. Similar is true for indoor=yes
without a surrounding building polygon.
Attachments (0)
Change History (6)
comment:1 Changed 8 months ago by
comment:2 Changed 8 months ago by
Also I just think of a building overhang or arcades (e.g. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arkade#/media/Datei:Arkadenhof_der_Universt%C3%A4t_Wien-2_1200.jpg) then a feature can be outside while being inside the building polygon in osm.
This was maybe even the reason for indoor=* and outdoor=* in the first place to mark things e.g. as outdoor while it seems to be indoor in the osm data.
comment:3 follow-up: 4 Changed 8 months ago by
I think both indoor=*
and outdoor=*
with identical values does not make sense but thanks for the reminder of outdoor=*
.
In my opinion, we still need a layer=*
for overhangs of buildings, like arcades or roofs, respectively for features on top of buildings.
A situations where one of the tags is really useful are feature mounted on the wall like node/9819487704/history.
comment:4 follow-up: 5 Changed 8 months ago by
Replying to skyper:
I think both
indoor=*
andoutdoor=*
with identical values does not make sense.
Regarding the examples, we probably need a new tag for features which are partly indoor and partly outdoor.
comment:5 follow-up: 6 Changed 8 months ago by
If indoor=yes
means "completely indoors" and outdoor=yes
means "completely outdoors" then something that is partly indoors (and partly outdoors) could be described with
indoor=no
+ outdoor=no
(not completely indoors and not completely outdoors).
indoor=yes
+ outdoor=yes
used 65 times.
indoor=no
+ outdoor=no
used 2 times.
comment:6 Changed 8 months ago by
Replying to anonym:
... then something that is partly indoors (and partly outdoors) could be described with
indoor=no
+outdoor=no
That would be too confusing.
Some mappers think that something can have indoor=yes and outdoor=yes at the same time. Maybe this is not a good idea, but it is in the wiki, see: