Modify

Opened 12 months ago

#21595 new enhancement

Missmatches in comparison between ​ELI and JOSM imagery lists

Reported by: mdk Owned by: team
Priority: normal Milestone:
Component: Wiki content Version:
Keywords: Cc:

Description

There are several results in the wiki:ImageryCompare page, where there are identical entries (Same ID and same name) for "found in ELI but not in JOSM" and "found in JOSM but not in ELI". In these cases no comparison of the details could be done:

-: found in ELI but not in JOSM
+: found in JOSM but not in ELI

Same Name and ID

-  [AU] ACTmapi Imagery 2017 [ACT2017]
+  [AU] ACTmapi Imagery 2017 [ACT2017]

-  [AU] ACTmapi Imagery 2018 [ACT2018]
+  [AU] ACTmapi Imagery 2018 [ACT2018]

-  [US] Delaware 2012 Orthophotography [Delaware2012Orthophotography]
+  [US] Delaware 2012 Orthophotography [Delaware2012Orthophotography]

-  [US] Mesa County GIS Valleywide 2018 [MCGIS-County-Valleywide-Imagery-2018]
+  [US] Mesa County GIS Valleywide 2018 [MCGIS-County-Valleywide-Imagery-2018]

-  [US] Mesa County GIS NAIP 2015 [MCGIS-County-NAIP-Imagery-2015]
+  [US] Mesa County GIS NAIP 2015 [MCGIS-County-NAIP-Imagery-2015]

-  [US] Mesa County GIS NAIP 2017 [MCGIS-County-NAIP-Imagery-2017]
+  [US] Mesa County GIS NAIP 2017 [MCGIS-County-NAIP-Imagery-2017]

-  [MD] Moldova Ortophoto, Center part (2020) [MoldovaMap-2020_ortofoto_moldova_centru]
+  [MD] Moldova Ortophoto, Center part (2020) [MoldovaMap-2020_ortofoto_moldova_centru]

-  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2014) [Berlin-2014]
+  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2014) [Berlin-2014]

-  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2015) [Berlin-2015]
+  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2015) [Berlin-2015]

+  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2016) [Berlin-2016]
-  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2016) [Berlin-2016]

-  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2017) [Berlin-2017]
+  [DE] Berlin/Geoportal DOP20RGB (2017) [Berlin-2017]

-  OSM Inspector: Addresses [OSM_Inspector-Addresses]
+  OSM Inspector: Addresses [OSM_Inspector-Addresses]

-  OSM Inspector: Geometry [OSM_Inspector-Geometry]
+  OSM Inspector: Geometry [OSM_Inspector-Geometry]

-  OSM Inspector: Highways [OSM_Inspector-Highways]
+  OSM Inspector: Highways [OSM_Inspector-Highways]

-  OSM Inspector: Places [OSM_Inspector-Places]
+  OSM Inspector: Places [OSM_Inspector-Places]

-  OSM Inspector: Routing [OSM_Inspector-Routing]
+  OSM Inspector: Routing [OSM_Inspector-Routing]

-  OSM Inspector: Tagging [OSM_Inspector-Tagging]
+  OSM Inspector: Tagging [OSM_Inspector-Tagging]

-  [FR] Bayonne - Petit et Grand Bayonne 2019 [Bayonne_2019]
+  [FR] Bayonne - Petit et Grand Bayonne 2019 [Bayonne_2019]

-  [CH] swisstopo SWISSALTI3D [swisstopo_swissalti3d]
+  [CH] swisstopo SWISSALTI3D [swisstopo_swissalti3d]

-  [CH] swisstopo swissSURFACE3D [swisstopo_swisssurface3d]
+  [CH] swisstopo swissSURFACE3D [swisstopo_swisssurface3d]

-  [IT] Lombardia - Italy (CTR DBT) [Lombardia-Italy-CTR-DBT]
+  [IT] Lombardia - Italy (CTR DBT) [Lombardia-Italy-CTR-DBT]


Same ID but different names

-  [PL] Geoportal 2: Orthophotomap (latest aerial imagery) (WMTS) [Geoportal2-PL-aerial_image_WMTS]
+  [PL] Geoportal 2: Orthophotomap (aerial image) WMTS [Geoportal2-PL-aerial_image_WMTS]

-  [NL] PDOK aerial imagery Beeldmateriaal.nl 7,5cm (WMTS) latest [Actueel_orthoHR_WMTS]
+  [NL] PDOK aerial imagery Beeldmateriaal.nl 7,5cm (WMTS) [Actueel_orthoHR_WMTS]

-  OSM Inspector: Area [OSM_Inspector-Multipolygon]
+  OSM Inspector: Areas [OSM_Inspector-Multipolygon]

-  [NO] Kartverket Hiking Trails [kartverket-friluft]
+  [NO] Kartverket Trails overlay [kartverket-friluft]


Same name but different IDs (random find)

-  [US] PEMA Orthoimagery (6in) [PEMA_Orthoimagery]
+  [US] PEMA Orthoimagery (6in) [PEMA_Orthoimagery_2018_2020]

Wouldn't it make sense to take more focus on the ID to match entries? I think that is the goal of the ID.

Attachments (0)

Change History (0)

Modify Ticket

Change Properties
Set your email in Preferences
Action
as new The owner will remain team.
as The resolution will be set.
to The owner will be changed from team to the specified user.
The owner will change to mdk
as duplicate The resolution will be set to duplicate.The specified ticket will be cross-referenced with this ticket
The owner will be changed from team to anonymous.

Add Comment


E-mail address and name can be saved in the Preferences.

 
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.