Changes between Version 22 and Version 26 of Ticket #21396


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2022-02-09T17:35:39+01:00 (2 years ago)
Author:
skyper
Comment:

Replying to Klumbumbus:

I'm not in favor of natural=crevasse. While the total number is quite high (36k) this is used only on a few spots worldwide, see https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/?key=natural&value=crevasse&filter=all#map. I randomly checked one spot: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1czA There are 2432 ways on this little glacier alone. And with this detailed mapping it is probably highly outdated anyway. Also the wiki page says it is proposal approved, but on the linked proposal page (https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/crevasse) was never discussed or voted. It links to the proposal of natural=ridge which is unrelated. (If added nevertheless one day, a icon is here after 21440#comment:24)

Ignore it for now.

Replying to Klumbumbus:

type=turnlanes:turns

So I would deprecate it in favor of turn:lanes tags, however we also have the plugin "turnlanes". More opinions?

Replying to skyper:

Last week, I already wrote a PM to the author of the TurnLanes preset asking about removing it but without answer, so far. Actually, I never took a look at all the plugins about turn:lanes=* but the obsolete relation should not be supported as we have *:lanes=* tagging and the connectivity relations.

I never got an answer. The user did not make any changes on OSM the last two years, though. +1 for deprecating the plugin. Do we need warning about the obsolete relations or is ignoring the tag enough?


Meanwhile, there are more tags, I have updated the list in the description.

  • healthcare:speciality=general
  • indoor=area

Should be ignored.

  • craft=grinding_mill should be added to the external craft preset and ignored in core
  • product=* should be added to the man_made=work presets but so far only foot and charcoal have high numbers (20k+). The rest has only up to 3k uses and the values on the wiki are not significantly the ones with wiki pages. So I am not sure which ones to add besides food (taginfo

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #21396

    • Property Milestone 22.0122.02
  • Ticket #21396 – Description

    v22 v26  
    55
    66* building=stilt_house (added r18336)
    7 * leisure=sports_hall - 10871
    8 * man_made=courtyard - 18229
     7* craft=grinding_mill - 34201
     8* healthcare=alternative (''ignored'')
     9* healthcare:speciality=general - 19538
     10* indoor=area - 10145
     11* leisure=sports_hall - 12251
     12* man_made=courtyard - 21075
    913* maxweight:signed=no - 20886 (''ignored'')
    10 * natural=crevasse - 36232
    11 * oneway:moped=no - 10634
     14* military=trench - 10804
     15* natural=crevasse - 36226
     16* oneway:moped=no - 15649
    1217* opening_hours:signed=no - 14713 (''ignored'')
    1318* operator:type=public - 188232  (''ignored'')
    1419* plant:method=photovoltaic - 12060 (#21398)
     20* product=food - 34176
    1521* railway:radio=gsm-r - 83728  (''ignored'')
    1622* military=trench - 10168
    1723* surface=unhewn_cobblestone - 10049 (added r18336)
    18 * type=turnlanes:turns - 24105
    19 * vending=parcel_pickup;parcel_mail_in - 10161
     24* type=turnlanes:turns - 23990
     25* vending=parcel_pickup;parcel_mail_in - 10161 (''ignored'')
    2026
    2127I already added or ignored the obvious ones in r18242 / r18245