Validator marks no_entry and no_exit-restrictions as an error

[Peilscheibe]

There are the well documented restriction relations "no_entry" and "no_exit" (​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Relation:restriction) which are allowing

• one or more "from"-members for a no_entry-restriction
• one or more "to"-members for a no_exit-restriction

However the JOSM-validator is recognizing such relations as an error.

Please update the validation rules accordingly so these relation types are accepted with the valid member numbers as described.
The mentioned restriction types started to be documented somewhen in 2012 and I'm not aware of any issues with them as the definitions are pretty straightforward.

Thanks

[Don-vip]

They are not used much (682 and 254 times).

[skyper]

Not sure which warning this is about but a least part of it needs to be solved in presets, see #20833.

[GerdP]

A no-entry relation allows multiple from-ways, the no_exit relation allows multiple to-ways. That's the major difference to the other turn restrictions. JOSM doesn't allow multiple from- or to-ways.

[skyper]

Replying to GerdP:

A no-entry relation allows multiple from-ways, the no_exit relation allows multiple to-ways. That's the major difference to the other turn restrictions. JOSM doesn't allow multiple from- or to-ways.

Yes, that is why we need own presets with correct definition of the roles, #20833.

[Neuwessi11]

I want to support any people who are missing the no_entry-support by JOSM.
I think it doesn't matter if it is often used or not, because there are enough situations, where this restriction is the best way of tagging.

And did you ever contemplate that it would may be have a significant higher number of usage if JOSM would not mark it as an error?

[GerdP]

See also #17057

[taylor.smock]

Ticket #22042 has been marked as a duplicate of this ticket.