Veraltete protected Vorlage in josm?

[trash@…]

Bin gerade über ein Naturschutzgebiet bei uns in der Gegend gestolpert.
Das wiki sagt, protect_id ist deprecated
​Key:protect_id

Stattdessen gibt es den neuen key protect_class
​Key:protect_class

Vielleicht bitte einmal in josm die vorgeschlagenen keys überprüfen und eventuell anpassen.
Danke und viele Grüße
Olli

​http://www.openstreetmap.org/user/Ziltoidium

[skyper]

Do not know where you got the information from but there is no protect*=* key at all in the defaultpresets.

• Should validator warn about protect_id=* (auto fix) ?
• boundary=protected_area (​wiki) seem to be in use but we do not have a preset.

[anonymous]

Maybe it is no preset, just let me show you, what i did.
I added a node / an area and then wanted to add "protected.." to this area.

When pressing the first two letters "pr..", josm suggests me protect_class then.
Here is a screenshot at dropbox

​https://www.dropbox.com/s/177gk8uixt3gw69/josm_pr.png?dl=0

Olli

[Klumbumbus]

The autocompletion uses not only the tags defined in presets but also all the tags used in the downloaded data. So in your case there was probably an object which was tagged with protectet_class=* in the osm data you downloaded.

[anonymous]

Ah ok, maybe that´s the reason. Thanks!

[skyper]

Replying to Klumbumbus:

The autocompletion uses not only the tags defined in presets but also all the tags used in the downloaded data. So in your case there was probably an object which was tagged with protectet_class=* in the osm data you downloaded.

Another reason could be an external preset which includes the tag.