unglue POIs

[dieterdreist]

there is a regression for unglueing POIs (nodes with tags), now if you unglue a POI at a crossing all ways get unglued and the tags remain at all new end-nodes. Before only the POI was unglued (desired behaviour)

[Don-vip]

What version are you using ? Do you remember the last version working as you expect ?

[dieterdreist]

I'm on 6201, I have checked 6129, 6150, 6187 and they all had the same problem. Maybe this is a side effect of my switch from 1.6 to 1.7 java?
Java version: 1.7.0_25, Oracle Corporation, Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM
VM arguments: [-Xmx8192M, -Dsun.java2d.opengl=true]

[AlfonZ]

Referring to 9025-test1.osm​:
Select the traffic_signals node, UnGlue Ways. The node gets duplicated.

I have tried it with JOSM 6201, 6115, and couple of older builds as far as 3208. Same behaviour.
Java version: 1.6.0_45, Sun Microsystems Inc., Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM
Java version: 1.7.0_25, Oracle Corporation, Java HotSpot(TM) Client VM

[Don-vip]

Replying to AlfonZ:

I have tried it with JOSM 6201, 6115, and couple of older builds as far as 3208. Same behaviour.

Then it is no regression.

[dieterdreist]

I'm quite sure this did work at some point in time.

[skyper]

Yes, something did change, but maybe it was some other commit:

Ungluing a POI of a single way (middel node) does not really unglue the POI as the node with ID remains as way node and the POI gets an new ID.

Thought that the node gets complete unglued from way.

[AlfonZ]

Note: Although nodes and ways have positive IDs, they are fabricated and must not be uploaded!

[AlfonZ]

Replying to skyper:

Yes, something did change, but maybe it was some other commit:

Ungluing a POI of a single way (middel node) does not really unglue the POI as the node with ID remains as way node and the POI gets an new ID.

Thought that the node gets complete unglued from way.

Referring to 9025-test2.osm​:
Select the crossing node (ID 4), UnGlue Ways. The node gets unglued. Old node (still part of way) retains ID 4, no tags; new node is tagged crossing.
I have tried it with JOSM 6266, 6238, 6115 and couple of older builds as far as 1521. Same behaviour.

Maybe you are thinking of utilsplugin2's Extract node, in which the node that is part of the way gets new ID and extracted node retains ID and tags.
Then there is recently added Disconnect Node from Way, in which the node is no longer part of the way.

[Don-vip]

Between Unglue, Extract and Disconnect I think you should find the one that matches your need :)