Incorporate Taginfo into Validator (was: validator, unknown keys and values)

[dieterdreist]

I recently noticed that some keys and values that are described in the wiki are not known to validator. I am not sure if this was a temporal problem, but I decided to use the nice sqlite3 dump from Jochen Topf's taginfo to extract the keys and values that are defined in the wiki.

The original dumps can be downloaded here:
​http://taginfo.openstreetmap.de/download

attached are 2 list, one for the keys, one for k/v pairs. IMHO all these keys and k/v pairs should be known by JOSM validator as well as used in the autocompletion dictionary.

[dieterdreist]

textfile with tags defined in the wiki (from taginfo)

[dieterdreist]

textfile with keys defined in the wiki (from taginfo)

[Don-vip]

See also ​https://web.archive.org/web/20161228050448/https://www.mapbox.com/osmdev/2013/01/17/taginfo/ on how we could integrate Taginfo features into JOSM.

[GerdP]

We have a script to compare the presets with taginfo. So I think this ticket can be closed?

[dieterdreist]

I guess it can be closed, this ticket is from 9 years ago. It is also clear that the process of integrating tags into a positive whitelist (directly or indirectly) has to be done by people and cannot be completely automatically done.

[GerdP]

Yes, see also #17055