New conflict resolution with way combining prevents any combining

[anonymous]

I tried to combine two ways with exactly same set of tags (both have landuse=village_green and source=cuzk:km) - dialog "Conflicts when combining ways" always appears, listing these two tags and for each of them give drop down box with the tag value and "none" option. No matter if I press apply or cancel, the result is the same - no combining is done and the ways are kept as is.

JOSM Revision 2075

[Gubaer]

(In [2079]) fixed #3433: New conflict resolution with way combining prevents any combining

[Gubaer]

The conflict dialog isn't displayed anymore if there are neither tag nor relation conflicts.

I'm pretty sure, though, that your ways have been combined. You should see a respective command in the command list dialog and it should consist at least of one delete command and one change command.

[malenki]

Replying to Gubaer:

The conflict dialog isn't displayed anymore if there are neither tag nor relation conflicts.

It is displayed (again) when I try to merge two identical parts of ways which belong to the same relations. If no relation is involved the dialog doesn't show up.

[malenki]

PS: I just tried to resolve conflicts with that dialog while merging ways. Setting all tags at the dialog to identical values and click [accept], the dialog disppears and the ways remain unmerged. Am I missing something or is it the dialog which doesn't work?

[Gubaer]

Probably something is broken. I'm looking into it.

[Gubaer]

I can't see that something is broken (not in the sense that ways are not merged at all). Do you have a sample file?

[malenki]

I've tried now some minutes, the bug is not reliable reproducable. :( But I vow it is there, saw it with my own eyes... I will keep them open an tell news as soon as there are some :(

[stoecker]

Should be fixed inbetween. Reopen if not.