problems handling conflicts when two users edit the same onject

[Cobra]

I did some edits, wanted to upload them, and caused a conflict since someone else edited one of my objects while I was still working. So I refreshed data, resolved conflicts and tried again but didn't succeed in uploading; message was "Version mismatch: provided 8, Server had 9". When I saved data locally and looked at the ways causing errors I noticed that there are still informations (timestamp, user, version) of the previous version instead of the current one.

Revision is 1567 (latest josm-latest.jar as of now).

[Cobra]

I saved all data (after refreshing and resolving conflicts) locally and uploaded that file here: ​http://home.arcor.de/SLXViper/osm/data.osm

[Gubaer]

For which element did you get "Version mismatch: provided 8, Server had 9"? The error message should also include an element id. Was it a relation?

[Cobra]

Output on terminal is:

PUT http://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/changeset/create... OK
POST http://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/changeset/1071589/upload... Conflict
Error body: Version mismatch: Provided 8, server had: 9 of Way 27010139

PUT http://www.openstreetmap.org/api/0.6/changeset/1071589/close... OK

[Gubaer]

Way 27010139 (Version 8) is a complex update of ​Way 27010139 (Version 9):

• Way 27010139 (Version 8) includes more nodes
• some nodes (i.e. ​Node 296060414) have been removed from Way 27010139 (Version 8) (they are deleted in the local data set)

It seems that JOSM doesn't support conflict resolution for this case yet. It's similar to missing conflict resolution in relations, see #2512.

[stoecker]

Closed as duplicate of #2609.