Validierung für Fahrradstraßen

[chris66]

Hallo,
könnte eine Validierung für Fahrradstraßen in JOSM eingebaut werden?

Manchmal wird das bicycle=designated vergessen, was dann durch das laut WIKI notwendige vehicle=no das Radrouting unmöglich macht.

Pseudo-Code:

if highway=* and bicycle_road=yes and vehicle=no check if bicycle=* is set.
if not set: "Warning: bicycle_road without bicycle access".

[stoecker]

If you provide a patch with a working rule (see Rules), then chances are much higher you get that.

[skyper]

First I thought of regional rules but a ​`bicycle_road=yes` without access for bicycles is a worldwide error and likely with only limited access for bicycles, too.

[Limes11]

I implemented

way[highway][bicycle_road=yes][vehicle][vehicle!=yes][!bicycle] {
  throwWarning: "Warning: bicycle_road without bicycle access";
}

(that is, put this in a validator.mapcss file and loaded that in JOSM)

Works fine.

Only vehicle=no is problematic when additional signage indicates vehicle=destination/agricultural (which does happen)

[stoecker]

In 19659/josm:

fix #24943 - bicycle roads without access for bicycles - patch by Limes11 (modified)