Add healthcare-tagging as optional to the existing Facilities/Health group in defaultpresets.xml

[Kmpopppe]

As per ​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:healthcare the amenities 'clinic', 'dentist', 'doctors', 'hospital' and 'pharmacy' have equivalents in the healthcare=*-Tagging scheme. The proposal (​https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Healthcare) suggests to deprecate the aforementioned amenity=* Tags and replace them by healthcare=* - as there is still discussion and arguments going on about this, the agreed way seems to be tagging both variants on the same node.

To allow people to decide whether they want to add the healthcare=* tagging, the defaultpreset.xml should be changed like this (diff of the 16653 revision of defaultpresets.xml, line numbers might change in further revisions) - obviously, inline translation wouldn't be necessary if it was done on global level:

3847a3848,3850
>             <optional>
>                 <combo key="healthcare" text="Healthcare" de.text="Gesundheit" fr.text="Soins de santé" nl.text="Gezondheidszorg" values="hospital" default=""/>
>             </optional>
3854a3858,3860
>             <optional>
>                 <combo key="healthcare" text="Healthcare" de.text="Gesundheit" fr.text="Soins de santé" nl.text="Gezondheidszorg" values="clinic" default=""/>
>             </optional>
3861a3868,3870
>             <optional>
>                 <combo key="healthcare" text="Healthcare" de.text="Gesundheit" fr.text="Soins de santé" nl.text="Gezondheidszorg" values="doctors" default=""/>
>             </optional>
3868a3878,3880
>             <optional>
>                 <combo key="healthcare" text="Healthcare" de.text="Gesundheit" fr.text="Soins de santé" nl.text="Gezondheidszorg" values="dentist" default=""/>
>             </optional>
3876a3889,3891
>             <optional>
>                 <combo key="healthcare" text="Healthcare" de.text="Gesundheit" fr.text="Soins de santé" nl.text="Gezondheidszorg" values="pharmacy" default=""/>
>             </optional>

A full version of the defaultpresets.xml with the addition is available on GitHub: ​https://github.com/OSM-de/gists/blob/master/JOSM/trunk/resources/data/defaultpresets.xml

[skyper]

There is the external healthcare preset which includes the tags.

[Kmpopppe]

The external preset does not include any pharmacy tagging whatsoever. I'd still root for the internal presets to get this change so that people aren't required to load the external preset before they start working with health related tagging.

[mkoniecz]

People aren't required to load the external preset before they start working with health related tagging, for example amenity=hospital is AFAIK well supported.

healthcare=hospital adds nothing whatsoever to amenity=hospital

[skyper]

If people want to use new tags or disputed tags, there is the option of external presets. JOSM usually only supports one tagging system internally.

The advantage of external presets on the wiki is that it is easy to update or enhance them. So, just add pharmacy to the healthcare preset if you need it.

[Kmpopppe]

Will contact external preset authors for this. Thanks for getting back with a sensible proposal.

[Klumbumbus]

--> wiki:/Presets/Healthcare?action=diff&version=30