detect the same way forming a loop by being twice in a multipolygon

[aceman]

If a way is a member twice in the same multipolygon and the two occurrences are connected (their index in the relation is n and n+1), JOSM displays the relation fine, with a closed loop in the relation editor. There is also no warning about this. So while this "area" is closed, it is probably useless for a multipolygon.

You can observe this case in the history of way 188885975 .

[GerdP]

We have the errors

• "Multipolygon member(s) repeated with same role" and
• "Multipolygon member(s) repeated with different role"

for this, so what is missing?

[GerdP]

The test that produces these messages was introduced with r11157 (3 years ago)

[GerdP]

I tried to set the milestone but Trac only offers those in the future. Do I need special rights for this?

[aceman]

Yes, looks like those validator checks detect this error these days.
Thanks.

[Don-vip]

Replying to GerdP:

I tried to set the milestone but Trac only offers those in the future. Do I need special rights for this?

I wasn't aware of this. Please try to logout/login from Trac, I've given you full rights on milestones.

[GerdP]

I see no change. The drop-down list contains only milestones in the future and I cannot edit the field.

[GerdP]

Oops, seems I have the right to remove the milestone, but I cannot set it to 16.12 :(

[GerdP]

@Don-Vip: Please can you set the milestone again?