Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #10330, comment 27
- Timestamp:
- 2014-08-13T21:38:12+02:00 (11 years ago)
Legend:
- Unmodified
- Added
- Removed
- Modified
-
Ticket #10330, comment 27
initial v1 2 2 > One more thing: 3 3 > * If we only allow `volcano` on nodes we need to allow `ridge` on closed ways and relations as you need to be able to tag a crater. 4 I am still not sure how I feel about `ridge` being a closed way yet. When thinking of what a mountain or hilltop `ridge` is in reality. Ridges in general don't seems to wrap around and close in on themselves. Although, we need to support mapping the crater rim. Messing overpass scripts for `ridge`, I couldn't find a single case of a `closedway`. There is a ton of `way` for `ridge`. If we were to change `ridge` to `closedway` we would need to apply the same to `cliff`. My conclusion is to not add a `closedway` as it states in the wiki [http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:natural=volcano#Crater_rim] it encourages users to tag as a cliff or ridge if its large enough. 4 I am still not sure how I feel about `ridge` being a closed way yet. When thinking of what a mountain or hilltop `ridge` is in reality. Ridges in general don't seems to wrap around and close in on themselves. Although, we need to support mapping the crater rim. Messing with overpass scripts for `ridge`, I couldn't find a single case of a `closedway`. There is a ton of `way` for `ridge`. If we were to change `ridge` to `closedway` we would need to apply the same to `cliff`. My conclusion is to not add a `closedway` as it states in the wiki [http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:natural=volcano#Crater_rim] it encourages users to tag as a cliff or ridge if its large enough. 5 5 6 6 I support adding `relation` to cliff and ridge in this case.
