Changes between Initial Version and Version 7 of Ticket #8460


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2016-03-05T16:38:04+01:00 (9 years ago)
Author:
simon04
Comment:

(Numbers for later reference added)

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • Ticket #8460

    • Property Cc skyper simon04 added
    • Property Keywords public_transport role check added
    • Property Milestone → 16.03

  • Ticket #8460 – Description

    initial v7  
     11.
     2
    13If a type=route relation is a member of a type=route_master relation, it should be viewed as a route according to the accepted Public Traffic Proposal
    2 http://wiki.openstreetmap.orgwiki/Proposed_features/Public_Transport and the error messages should include the following items.
     4osmwiki:Proposed_features/Public_Transport and the error messages should include the following items.
    35
    46(Citations from the proposal are marked with "PTP" here.)
    … …  
    79
    810-----------
    9 -----------
    1011
    11 The only roles are "stop", "platform", "stop_exit_only", "stop_entry_only",
    12 "platform_exit_only", "platform_entry_only" and "".
     122.
    1313
    14 PTP: "Each direction/variant relation contains all available «stop_positions»,
    15 «platforms» and ways."
     14The only roles are "stop", "platform", "stop_exit_only", "stop_entry_only", "platform_exit_only", "platform_entry_only" and "".
     15
     16PTP: "Each direction/variant relation contains all available «stop_positions», «platforms» and ways."
    1617
    1718PTP: "If a stop is only for exiting or entering the vehicle (common for nightly services) the roles stop and platform should be replaced with stop_exit_only or stop_entry_only and platform_exit_only or platform_entry_only."
    … …  
    2122-----------
    2223
     243.
     25
    2326All "" entries (tour ways) refer to OSM Ways and follow as a block at the end of the relations member list.
    2427
    … …  
    2629
    2730-----------
     31
     324.
    2833
    2934If exactly two entries with the same name or belonging to the same stop_area follow each other, the entry with the role "stop" should be before the entry "platform". This should not be an error but a warning, as both may refer to two different stops of the vehicle.
    … …  
    3338-----------
    3439
     405.
     41
    3542The tag route does not have a value light_rail. All trains should be marked with train. The same holds for route=light_train. (The railway infrastructure may be different.)
    3643
    … …  
    3946-----------
    4047
    41 The name of a route should have the form
    42 PTP: "<vehicle type> <reference number>: <initial stop> => <terminal stop>"
     486.
    4349
    44 and the route_master name should have the form
    45 PTP: "<Vehicle type> <Reference number>"
     50The name of a route should have the form PTP: "<vehicle type> <reference number>: <initial stop> => <terminal stop>"
     51and the route_master name should have the form PTP: "<Vehicle type> <Reference number>"
    4652
    4753This should be warnings only as the mappers need some more flexibility:
    … …  
    5662-----------
    5763
     647.
     65
    5866A node with the role platform may not have any infrastructure in the Public Traffic Proposal. So shelter=yes, tactile_paving=yes or bench=yes should lead to an error message (shelter=yes only a warning as it is also used to indicate a shelter belonging to a shop at the stop)
    5967
    … …  
    6472-----------
    6573
     748.
     75
    6676There is no public_transport=stop_area_group
    6777
     78