Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #3733, comment 5


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2012-06-02T14:40:12+02:00 (12 years ago)
Author:
skyper

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #3733, comment 5

    initial v1  
    11from !#7741 [ticket:7741 AM909]:
    2 > In r5181:
    3 >
    4 > The validator's "similar named ways" gives incorrect warnings in (at least) the following situations:
    5 >
    6 > * "East Foothill Drive" and "West Foothill Drive": Should not report when the diffs are just leading or trailing cardinal directions. Can be tested by a second pass at reported errors. Run both args through '''''{{{s/East |West |North |South | East| West| North| South//g}}}''''' and then diff again. If no diff, no error should be reported.
    7 >
    8 > * "5th Street" and "6th Street": Should not report when the diffs are only leading numbers. Similar to above, remove all leading numbers ('''''{{{1st |2nd |First |Second |etc.}}}''''') and diff again. No diff = no report.
     2>> In r5181:
     3>>
     4>> The validator's "similar named ways" gives incorrect warnings in (at least) the following situations:
     5>>
     6>> * "East Foothill Drive" and "West Foothill Drive": Should not report when the diffs are just leading or trailing cardinal directions. Can be tested by a second pass at reported errors. Run both args through '''''{{{s/East |West |North |South | East| West| North| South//g}}}''''' and then diff again. If no diff, no error should be reported.
     7>>
     8>> * "5th Street" and "6th Street": Should not report when the diffs are only leading numbers. Similar to above, remove all leading numbers ('''''{{{1st |2nd |First |Second |etc.}}}''''') and diff again. No diff = no report.
     9>>
     10>> In the bounding box (34.0600548, -117.7425385, 34.1251634, -117.6477814) (BLTR), at least 50 of the 56 reported "similar named ways" fall into one of these two (invalid) scenarios.
    911
    10 and
    1112
    1213[comment:1 mdk]:
    1314> The same problem about railway platform names like "Gleis 1" and "Gleis 2".
    1415>
    15 > In the bounding box (34.0600548, -117.7425385, 34.1251634, -117.6477814) (BLTR), at least 50 of the 56 reported "similar named ways" fall into one of these two (invalid) scenarios.
     16
     17
     18EDIT: fix. @AM909: sorry