Changes between Initial Version and Version 2 of Ticket #20995


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2021-06-13T22:24:48+02:00 (5 years ago)
Author:
roqimas
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • Ticket #20995 – Description

    initial v2  
    77There are a ton of obvious benefits to having unified presets. Data quality of OSM, ease of use for editors, communicability of editing practices, accuracy of rendering by editors would all increase massively if presets (and therefore tagging schemes) were standardized more. The wiki, in integrating that standard preset scheme, could offer even better documentation of those tagging schemes. Changes in tagging could easily propagate across geography and time, past tagging could be understood better as a result of previous unified standards, editing and adding data would be simplified considerably and the barrier of entry for new editors (and editor solutions) would be lowered as well.
    88
    9 Why haven't there been more attempts at integrating the presets JOSM, Potlach, iD and other editing solutions use? We see some convergence; StreetComplete uses iD's presets, Vespucci uses JOSM's. But still, a (imo highly unnecessary) rift remains, only getting worse with time as more editors, editing solutions and tagging discrepancies emerge.
     9Why haven't there been more attempts at integrating the presets JOSM, Potlach, iD and other editing solutions use? We see some convergence; StreetComplete uses iD's presets, Vespucci uses JOSM's. But still, a (IMO highly unnecessary) rift remains, only getting worse with time as more editors, editing solutions and tagging discrepancies emerge.