Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #14528, comment 80


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2017-12-08T20:52:23+01:00 (6 years ago)
Author:
cmuelle8

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #14528, comment 80

    initial v1  
    55If you create a MP with one outer (1) and one inner way (2) and draw a closed way (3) intersecting both, then select all three ways (without the relation in the selection), the operation will create a new MP with a correct result.  But the user is also asked to 'fix' the old MP by querying him to keep/remove (meaningless, because altered!) ways, which most of the time results in a broken relation:
    66* ways queried about in the keep/remove dialogs do not exist in their previous form
    7 * user cannot decide meaningfully what to keep or remove (i.e. 'bling flight')
     7* user cannot decide meaningfully what to keep or remove (i.e. 'blind flight')
    88* the result of readding ways to the relations they have been taken out of is, from a user perspective, unpredictable
    99* this appears to be a problem with as little as one multipolygon in the input (it may be worse with larger input)