Changes between Initial Version and Version 1 of Ticket #12609, comment 12


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2016-03-13T07:41:56+01:00 (9 years ago)
Author:
openstreetmap.org-user-d1g

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • Ticket #12609, comment 12

    initial v1  
    2323Instead of single source of truth "core preset" you delegate this to EVERY single end-user... They have to pick and check every of 99 sources.
    2424
    25 It is similar if there dictionary only words staring with A, then with B, then with C. Yes there only 28 letters, but why would you need this granularity in presets in the first place?
     25It is similar if there dictionary only words staring with A, a separate book with B, a separate book with C. Yes there only 28 letters, but why would you need this granularity in presets in the first place?
    2626
    27 Only to say that "developer/maintainer of A preset didn't update it in time?" not a "core JOSM developer"? Or "presets A and C could do this?" not a core preset (JOSM core preset is almost empty by iD standards)
     27Most mappers want '''only popular and correct words''' (tags) not all millions from Taginfo (meaningless tag are wasting everybody time) or only 10 "core" (in JOSM).
     28
     29There no point in teaching that ''natural=tree'' is for "tree" or learning this "skill".
     30
     31There no skill or knowledge in this. There no need in dedicated presets for "a tree". It's only a technical limitation or approach to manage tags, not to solve our problem (When to tags and which?)
     32
     33IMO this policy was created only to say that "developer/maintainer of A preset didn't update it in time?" not a "core JOSM developer"? Or "presets A and C could do this?" not a core preset (JOSM core preset is almost empty by iD standards)
    2834
    2935> If the goal of a osm mapper is to see "'''captions in his language'''" then he is doing something wrong.