Changes between Version 4 and Version 5 of Ticket #12427, comment 28


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2016-01-26T12:04:54+01:00 (10 years ago)
Author:
cmuelle8

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Ticket #12427, comment 28

    v4 v5  
    1313
    1414-----
    15 I'm also +1 on having Lambert's formula in JOSM code, but IMO it won't replace the need for something iterative/recursive that operates on ever reduced partial segments. E.g. if we had a function ''unlike'' {{{getCenter()}}}, one that indeed does return a center (or near center) LatLon coordinate lying on a "great ellipse" (if true distance matters: on a geodesic), we can dream about approximating geoid distances as well (by combining it with the srtm data, or by points having 'ele' tags in the db): We can't do such things using "plain" distance functions, I suppose.  Of course, this won't happen overnight and unit tests along that path, may we choose it, should not be forgotten.
     15I'm +1 on having Lambert's formula in JOSM code, but IMO it won't replace the need for something iterative/recursive that operates on ever reduced partial segments. E.g. if we had a function ''unlike'' {{{getCenter()}}}, one that indeed does return a center (or near center) LatLon coordinate lying on a "great ellipse" (if true distance matters: on a geodesic), we can dream about approximating geoid distances as well (by combining it with the srtm data, or by points having 'ele' tags in the db): We can't do such things using "plain" distance functions, I suppose.  Of course, this won't happen overnight and unit tests along that path, may we choose it, should not be forgotten.
    1616
    1717Lastly, lets take note of one very interesting thing about geodesics on the ellipsoid: If there is more than one geodesic connecting two points they are very likely to have ''different'' distances on the geoid, i.e. using the geoid we'll find out which of the geodesic arcs is the true shortest of ''shortest arcs''. This won't matter at all for aerial or marinal navigation though.. It's more food for thought.