Changes between Version 14 and Version 17 of Ticket #12386


Ignore:
Timestamp:
2016-01-17T14:26:45+01:00 (10 years ago)
Author:
Klumbumbus
Comment:

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • Ticket #12386 – Description

    v14 v17  
    1717|| [osmwiki:Tag:power=insulator] || node, way || ✔ || not needed ||
    1818|| [osmwiki:Tag:power=catenary_mast] || node || Not in Preset, see #12297 || - ||
    19 || [osmwiki:Tag:power=transformer] || node || Used 8944 times on ways. Keep preset as is || not needed ||
     19|| [osmwiki:Tag:power=transformer] || node || ✔ Done. || ✔ Done. ||
    2020|| [osmwiki:Tag:power=switch] or [osmwiki:Tag:power=pole]+switch=yes or [osmwiki:Tag:power=tower]+switch=yes || node || ✔ || not needed ||
    2121|| [osmwiki:Tag:power=substation] || node, area || ✔ || not needed (area style not closed warning for unclosed ways already there) ||
    … …  
    3333And add a few more :
    3434||= Rule =||= Description =||= Progress =||
    35 || A [osmwiki:Tag:power=cable] without [osmwiki:Key:location] || A power cable is a feature which must be set in a dedicated location such as indoor, underground or undersea (non exhaustive list). Any power cable object without the location key may show up a validation warning. || ✔ Wiki says that location=* is optional and that underground is the assumed default value for power=cable. However 5290 out of 7963 cables have the location tag (http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/dMQ). So add this as info level. ||
     35|| A [osmwiki:Tag:power=cable] without [osmwiki:Key:location] || A power cable is a feature which must be set in a dedicated location such as indoor, underground or undersea (non exhaustive list). Any power cable object without the location key may show up a validation warning. || ✔ Done. Wiki says that location=* is optional and that underground is the assumed default value for power=cable. However 5290 out of 7963 cables have the location tag (http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/dMQ). So add this as info level. ||
    3636|| Crossing between road, railroad, path, landuse, waterways and power ways || Power lines may be long objects crossing through country and mappers can easily place nodes in common with roads or landuse areas. A validation error should be prompted to reduce the amount of such problems. ||  ||
    37 || Missing voltage as important information || Adding [osmwiki:Key:voltage] to [osmwiki:Tag:power=line], [osmwiki:Tag:power=minor_line], [osmwiki:Tag:power=cable], [osmwiki:Tag:power=generator], [osmwiki:Tag:power=transformer] or [osmwiki:Tag:power=plant] is a really useful information and miss this key should prompt an info validation message. Voltage is currently one main threshold to distinguish line from minor_line. ||  ||
     37|| Missing voltage as important information || Adding [osmwiki:Key:voltage] to [osmwiki:Tag:power=line], [osmwiki:Tag:power=minor_line], [osmwiki:Tag:power=cable], [osmwiki:Tag:power=generator], [osmwiki:Tag:power=transformer] or [osmwiki:Tag:power=plant] is a really useful information and miss this key should prompt an info validation message. Voltage is currently one main threshold to distinguish line from minor_line. || ✔ Done. ||
    3838
    3939These lists can be improved according to the experience of contributors and developers