id	summary	reporter	owner	description	type	status	priority	milestone	component	version	resolution	keywords	cc
4543	Merge problem: potential defect in merge logic	Gubaer	team	"Creating a new ticket from a message in #4509, see also [https://josm.openstreetmap.de/attachment/ticket/4509/josm_error_%234509.tar.bz2 attached file].

Not qualifying as r-2010-01-blocker yet, needs analysis first.

----

Sorry for making so much work, but weekend is over and I am back again.

I think there is still a bug in merging. I have to older osm of the same region. I think the only thing I edit is deleting errors (overlaping way, doubled nodes). I do not find any id:0.

I merge this files and only get conflicts of nodes, but there exist ways in one osm that do not exist in the other one. I think there should be an conflict on but please tell me if I am wrong. Look for the round-about ""Siegesdenkmal"" and there at the low left. I also noticed that there is no conflict of a relation, but this way (42667459) still exists but lost its membership.

I merged the older file onto the new, but I think it also is not working right the other way round. May we have to open another ticket.

Cheers skyper


"	defect	closed	critical		Core	latest	invalid	merge	skyper