id	summary	reporter	owner	description	type	status	priority	milestone	component	version	resolution	keywords	cc
12496	Verify properly tagged islands and islets	naoliv	team	"http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:place#Other_places says:

`place=island` → area > 1 km²
`place=islet` → area < 1 km²

{{{
#!mapcss

area:closed[place = islet][eval(areasize()) > 1000] {
        throwWarning: tr(""islet with wrong classification"");
        suggestAlternative: ""place=island"";
        fixAdd: ""place=island"";
}

area:closed[place = island][eval(areasize()) < 1000] {
        throwWarning: tr(""island with wrong classification"");
        suggestAlternative: ""place=islet"";
        fixAdd: ""place=islet"";
}
}}}

island|islet with exactly 1 km² is in limbo.
It needs a better warning message, probably.

But it needs to have #11516 fixed to also work with relations.

Is it interesting to have this test in JOSM?"	enhancement	closed	normal	16.02	Core validator		fixed	mapcss island islet place